Amazon, we want to talk to you about Kindle Unlimited

Helen Leesh, librarian and co-chair of Shelf Free, has published an advocacy letter ‘Amazon we want to talk to you about Kindle Unlimited’ on the Chartered Institute of Library Professionals Website.

The article raises some interesting points, especially regarding the possibility of Amazon and public libraries working in partnership. This would allow public libraries to provide access to more new release/bestseller ebook titles and provide Amazon with the opportunity to act as a community partner and to reach new customers.

CILIP: strict limits on library ebook lending must end

The Chartered Institute of Library and Information Professionals (UK) has called for the end of stringent lending limitations on ebooks through public libraries.

Of the six major trade publishers in the UK, only three (HarperCollins, Random House and Hachette) offer ebooks to public libraries. Research conducted by Shelf Free in 2013 found that 85% of ebooks were not available to public libraries. Out of the top 50 most borrowed adult fiction books of 2012, only 7 were made available by publishers for libraries to lend electronically.

The full press release is available here.

Over 5 000 HarperCollins e-book titles now available on OverDrive UK

Over 5,000 HarperCollins e-book titles are now available on OverDrive for UK customers, including school, public and university libraries. Borrowing terms are the same as for U.S titles: each copy purchased may be borrowed 26 times before its license expires and a new copy must be purchased. The Overdrive blog post is available here.

Tender for Library Authorities to join UK e-lending pilots

The Society of Chief Librarians and the Publisher’s Association have released an invitation to tender titled Testing the impact of e-lending both on-site and remotely upon the Public Library and Publishing sectors.

One of the recommendations of the Sieghart review of library e-lending in the UK was that a series of pilots be constructed to test remote e-lending, based on one user-one copy, and that copy would deteriorate after an agreed number of loans. The pilots are intended to provide publishers, authors, agents and libraries with an evidence base to assess what happens to lending and purchasing behaviour in those areas.

The SCL and PA appointed research and strategy consultancy MTM London to design the pilot projects in August 2013.

The current tender calls for Library Authorities to participate in the pilots. Four authorities will participate, one each that:

  • represents a largely rural population and will loan e-books for 7 days
  • represents a largely rural population and will loan e-books for 21 days
  • represents a largely metropolitan population and will loan e-books for 7 days
  • represents a largely metropolitan population and will loan e-books for 21 days

Each participating authority will be required to purchase a pre-agreed set of approximately 1,000 titles, made up of front- and back-list titles from major publishers, prominent UK authors and new titles as they are published.

As well as meeting the standard requirements from publishers and platform providers, the participating authorities will be required to include a ‘click to buy’ button for all titles included in the project.

Participating authorities will be required to report on the changes in physical and e-lending habits of clients during the pilot. The pilots are intended to run for 12 months to December 2014.

SCL and the Publishers Association invite tenders on e-lending research project

One of the recommendations of the UK’s Sieghart review into e-lending in public libraries was:

A number of pilots in 2013 using established literary events should be set up to test business models and user behaviours, and provide a transparent evidence base: all major publishers and aggregators should participate in these pilots

In June 2013, the Society of Chief Librarians and the Publishers Association released a Request for Proposal to appoint a research agency to co-design (with SCL and PA) and evaluate a number of research pilots which will test the impact of e-lending.

The key research questions are:

  • What is the reader journey? i.e. how do library users find and access e-books?
  • What is the impact on sales?
  • What is the overall impact on library services?
  • How does an e-lending offer change the customers’ perception of library services?

The deadline for proposals was July 17.

UPDATE: The contract to develop the pilots was awarded to MTM London, a research and strategy consultancy.

Shelf Free

Shelf Free is a group of individuals in the UK, who believe that e-books and e-lending should be an important part of services for public library users. Shelf Free is made up of representatives from at least 19 public library systems, consultancies and CILIP (although it is not clear if they represent those organisations in a formal capacity).

At present, the aims of Shelf Free seem to be raising awareness of the issues with e-books and e-lending in public libraries amongst people who work in libraries, the book trade, and library users.

Shelf Free’s own position statement on e-book services in public libraries and the range of titles provided states that they acknowledge the challenges that e-books represent to established publishing business models, but urges all publishers and libraries to cooperate in providing e-book services to library users, particularly in light of the recommendations of the Sieghart review.

Two more via Twitter – “WMF panel: libraries need national e-lending model” & “OverDrive Launches Digital Library Champions Contest”

Today’s twitter search on #ebooks and #libraries brings us the following:

The Bookseller reports on UK policy group Westminster Forum Projects‘ Westminster Media Forum on publishing.  Highlights included Tim Coates, CEO of e-book company Bilbary suggesting a patron driven model allowing “readers to access books from a national catalogue, with the library paying a fee to the publisher for each loan“; Janene Cox, president of the Society of Chief Librarians, reporting that the Sieghart Review had found “remote e-lending has meant more people and more actual library visits, not less” and  Phil Bradley, president of CILIP, saying:

Libraries are about books as much as hospitals are about beds. In both cases they are integral to what is done—but libraries are not just about books . . . they are about reading—and in many respects, it doesn’t matter if [people] are reading a physical item or a digital copy.

Goodereader reports that major ebook platform provider Overdrive has launched a Digital Library Champions Contest.  

The contest centers around five different aspects of marketing and promotion and Overdrive is serious about libraries blazing their own trail and not being reliant on stock marketing materials.

Winners receive $500.00 in eBook credits, an e-Reader and promotion on their main website.

An Independent Review of E-lending in Public Libraries in England – Report

The UK’s Department for Culture, Media & Sport has released the Independent report into e-lending in UK public libraries. This report is the culmination of the review announced in September 2012 and headed by William Sieghart.

The report’s main recommendations are:

  • Public libraries should be able to offer on-site and off-site e-lending services to clients that are free at point of use
  • That Public Lending Right should be extended to audio books and e-books loaned on-site and off-site through public libraries
  • That the interests of publishers and booksellers should be protected by extending the ‘friction’ present in print loans to the e-lending environment. i.e. Copies should only be loaned to one client at a time, copies should be securely removed at the end of the loan period, and copies of e-books should ‘deteriorate’ after a certain number of loans. (This is essentially the current model used to access Harper Collins titles through Overdrive)
  • Pilot research projects should be undertaken to test business models and user behaviour, and provide a transparent evidence base

The Government’s response
seems broadly supportive of these recommendations, although e.g. is careful not to appear to commit additional money to PLR.

The British Library Trust has already agreed to fund pilot research projects, and publishers have agreed to cooperate with the Society of Chief Librarians, Arts Council England and the Reading Agency to undertake pilots as part of existing initiatives such as World Book Night.

Press release – Review of E-lending Published

Independent review of e-lending in public libraries – UK

The review was announced by Culture Minister Ed Vaizey on 26 september 2012. It will be headed by William Sieghart and will consider:

  • the benefits of e-lending
  • the current nature and level of e-lending and projection of future demand
  • Current supply models, barriers to the supply of e-books to libraries, and likely future trends
  • Systems for remunerating authors / publishers for e-lending
  • The impact of e-lending on publishers and their business models
  • Any unforeseen consequences of e-lending, including the long term impact on library premises, the impact on those who cannot keep up with changes in technology, skills requirements for librarians etc.

Submissions to the panel closed on 6 November, 2012, and the panel’s review is due to be produced in early 2013.

The panel’s terms of reference should be available at, but at time of writing this document was not available on the DCMS website. However, the document has been archived by the UK National Archives and is available through the UK Government Web Archive – Terms of Reference.

Announcement of the review on the DCMS website
Press release announcing the review